It is one of the most iconic images of the Civil War - a photograph of thirteen officers of the 28th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry and a civilian. The photograph, likely taken in June of 1865, has been reproduced in numerous books on the Civil War and the Irish Brigade.
But who are the men in the photograph? For years, many of them had been misidentified. The original photograph is housed at the Huntington Library in California, and the names identified in the photograph is based on a piece of paper attached to the photograph.
So, who are the men in the photograph.

The officers standing are from left to right are listed on the paper as 1st Lieutenant Michael Powderly, 1st Lieutenant Thomas Cook, 1st Lieutenant John Knight, the civilian named Mr. McParland, 2nd Lieutenant George Beattie, 1st Lieutenant John Miner, 2nd Lieutenant William McCarthy, Assistant Surgeon Albert Chase, and 2nd Lieutenant John McGlim.
Seated officers from left to right are listed as Captain John Miles, Captain Patrick Black, Lieutenant Colonel James Flemming, Captain Patrick Bird, and Captain John Coriness.
However, looking at the roster of the regiment, one can determine that some of the names and even ranks are incorrect with the original roster listed in
Massachusetts Soldiers, Sailors and Marines in the War of the Rebellion.
So, let us take a closer look at the men in the photograph.
The first officer standing on the left is 1st Lieutenant Michael Powderly. Powderly was a 22 year old shoemaker when, on September 28th, 1861, he enlisted as a Corporal in Company D. Powderly made it through the early battles of the regiment without being wounded, and re-enlisted on January 1st, 1864 with the rank of Sergeant. Powderly was wounded on May 18th, 1864 at Spotsylvania and was commissioned a 1st Lieutenant on July 21st, 1864. While awaiting his mustering at the rank of 1st Lieutenant, Powderly served as the regiment's Sergeant Major from September 1st to November 11th, 1864. On June 30th, 1865, Powderly was mustered out of service with the rank of 1st Lieutenant of Company D.
The next officer is Thomas Cook, identified as a 1st Lieutenant. This is misleading, as Thomas Cook, a Boston printer, was actually a 2nd Lieutenant at the time of the photograph. He had been commissioned as a 1st Lieutenant on April 26th, 1865, but was never mustered in at that rank, and thus he ended the war as the 2nd Lieutenant of Company E when he was mustered out on June 30th, 1865. Cook had enlisted on January 23rd, 1862 and was wounded at Fredericksburg, Gettysburg, Spotsylvania, and Deep Bottom, Virginia.
1st Lieutenant John Knight was a 21 year old varnisher from Boston when he enlisted in Company B on December 13th, 1861. On September 17th, 1862, he was wounded at Antietam, Maryland, and, upon re-enlisting on February 20th, 1864, he had been promoted to Sergeant. He was commissioned a 1st Lieutenant on July 19th, 1864, but, before mustering in, was wounded and captured on August 25th, 1864 at Ream's Station, Virginia, but was paroled soon after, and remained in a hospital in Baltimore, Maryland until he was either exchanged or recovered to rejoin his regiment. Knight was mustered out on June 30th, 1865.
The civilian identified as Mr. McParland is unknown. Perhaps he was a local civilian, or a civilian agent from Massachusetts, the Christian Commission, or the Sanitary Commission.
2nd Lieutenant George Beatty has the misfortune of having his surname misspelled as Beattie. Beatty was a 19 year old tinsmith when he joined as a Private in Company B on January 6th, 1862. Somewhere along the road, he was promoted to Sergeant, and in the Spring of 1864, he was promoted to 1st Sergeant. On May 9th, 1864, he was wounded at the Po River, commissioned a 2nd Lieutenant in Company D on February 24th, 1865 (mustering in on March 15th), and was wounded on April 2nd, 1865, at the South Side Railroad - the regiment's last action. He was mustered out on June 30th, 1865.
John Miner was 24 and a cloth printer from Worcester when he enlisted as a Corporal in Company B on October 9th, 1861. On November 1st, 1862, he was promoted to Quartermaster Sergeant and served at that rank until he was commissioned a 1st Lieutenant in Company E on May 22nd, 1864. On June 30th, 1865, he was mustered out. He is one of three officers in the photograph who had avoided being wounded in action.
William McCarty (not McCarthy) was a 25 year old carpenter from West Roxbury. On October 11th, 1861, he enlisted in Company A, and seems to have made it through all the early engagements of the regiment without injury. He re-enlisted on January 1st, 1864, and on May 12th, 1864, was wounded during the attack on the Mule Shoe at Spotsylvania. On July 18th, 1864, he was promoted to Quartermaster Sergeant (taking over probably for Miner). In February of 1865, he was commissioned a 2nd Lieutenant in Company C, was mustered in at that rank on March 15th, 1865. On July 19th, 1865, he became one of the last members of the regiment to muster out.
Assistant Surgeon Albert Chase was from Meredith, New Hampshire. He was one of the newcomers in the regiment, having been commissioned as an Assistant Surgeon on April 7th, 1865. The regiment had not been with an Assistant Surgeon since July 30th, 1863, when Assistant Surgeon Peter Hubon resigned. Chase was mustered out on June 30th, 1865.
The last officer standing is 2nd Lieutenant John McGlinn (spelled McGlim on the paper). McGlinn was an 18 year old laborer from Boston when he joined Company C at Fort Columbus, New York Harbor on January 28th, 1862. Upon his re-enlistment on January 1st, 1864, he was promoted to Corporal. On April 16th, 1864, he was promoted to Sergeant, and served in that rank through the Overland Campaign and Petersburg. On January 14th, 1865, McGlinn was commissioned as a 2nd Lieutenant in Company A and was mustered the following month. On June 30th, 1865, he mustered out, never having been wounded.
The officer sitting on the left is Captain John Miles. Miles was a 22 year old carver from Boston who enlisted as a Corporal in Company E on October 2nd, 1861. By his re-enlistment on January 1st, 1864, he had been promoted to 1st Sergeant of Company E. Miles was wounded on May 5th, 1864 at The Wilderness, and two weeks after his wounding, he received a commission to 1st Lieutenant. However, before he mustered as a 1st Lieutenant, he was promoted to Captain of Company E on August 7th, 1864, and was wounded on August 25th, 1864 at Ream's Station. Miles returned to the regiment in time to pose for the photograph, and was mustered out on June 30th, 1865.
Captain Patrick Black previously served in the 9th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry, the first Irish regiment formed in Massachusetts. Black was a central figure in the recruiting/commission scandal in 1864. Colonel Richard Byrnes, the commander of the 28th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry, was on recruiting duty in Boston when he met Black. Byrnes was impressed with Black's prior service and offered Black a commission as a 2nd Lieutenant. The state records indicated that Black was paid a bounty payment, which he was not entitled too, and suspicions arose that Byrnes was selling commissions to friends. Black was never actually paid a bounty, and an inquiry brought by Governor John Andrew cleared Black and another man of any wrongdoing and Black was allowed to retain his commission. On May 5th, 1864, Black was commissioned a 1st Lieutenant. On July 21st, 1864, Black was promoted to Captain of Company D and mustered the following November. Black was commissioned a Major on April 9th, 1865, but never mustered at that rank, and he mustered out of service on July 22nd, 1865.
Lieutenant Colonel James Fleming had his name incorrectly spelled as Flemming. Fleming was a 19 year old upholsterer from Boston when he enlisted as a 1st Sergeant in Company B on October 4th, 1861. On August 9th, 1862, Fleming was commissioned a 2nd Lieutenant, and then commissioned a 1st Lieutenant on November 15th, 1862. Fleming was wounded at the Battle of Fredericksburg, but returned to the regiment in time to be commissioned a Captain on May 29th, 1863. Fleming was wounded on May 18th, 1864 at Spotsylvania, and when he returned to action, he assumed command of the regiment, and on July 21st, 1864, was promoted to Major. Fleming was commissioned a Lieutenant Colonel on November 30th, 1864, and assumed formal command of the regiment on December 19th, 1864, following Colonel George Cartwright's discharge. On March 25th, 1865, Fleming sustained his third wound while in action at Hatcher's Run. Fleming's wound kept him out of action for the remainder of the war, as Black was in command of the regiment when the regiment returned to Washington on May 15th, 1865. Fleming was mustered out on July 19th, 1865.
Captain Patrick Bird was an 18 year old carriage painter from Chelsea when he enlisted in Company B on January 10th, 1862. He was wounded at Second Bull Run while serving as a Corporal, and was a Sergeant when he was wounded at Fredericksburg. When he re-enlisted on January 1st, 1864, he was a 1st Sergeant, and was thereafter promoted to Sergeant Major. On May 22nd, 1864, he was commissioned a 1st Lieutenant of Company A, was wounded a third time at Cold Harbor. On August 16th, 1864, Bird was promoted to Captain, and was wounded a fourth time on April 2nd, 1865 at the South Side Railroad. Bird was mustered out on June 30th, 1865.
Captain John Connor had the misfortune of having his surname misspelled as Coriness. He was an 18 year old farmer from Boston who enlisted as a Private in Company D on December 2nd, 1861. When he re-enlisted on January 1st, 1864, he was promoted to Sergeant, and on May 22nd, 1864, Connor was commissioned a 1st Lieutenant of Company C. Connor was wounded at Cold Harbor, and was advanced to the rank of Captain on August 16th, 1864. On March 25th, 1865, he was wounded at Hatcher's Run, and was mustered out on June 30th, 1865.